Original SONIC Smasher (Double) vs All-American SONIC Smasher (Double): Sonic Nutrition Compared
Quick answer: Original SONIC Smasher (Double) has 10 fewer calories than All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) (600 vs 610). Sodium is 120 mg lower in Original SONIC Smasher (Double) (1530 mg vs 1650 mg).
Original SONIC Smasher (Double) vs All-American SONIC Smasher (Double)
One serving each, as Sonic prints it.
The short answer
Original SONIC Smasher (Double) has 10 fewer calories than All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) (600 vs 610). Sodium is 120 mg lower in Original SONIC Smasher (Double) (1530 mg vs 1650 mg).
| Nutrient | Original SONIC Smasher (Double) | All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 600 | 610higher |
| Total fat | 37 g47% DV | 37 g47% DV |
| Saturated fat | 14 g70% DV | 14 g70% DV |
| Trans fat | 1 ghigher | 0.5 g |
| Cholesterol | 100 mg33% DV | 105 mghigher35% DV |
| Sodium | 1530 mg67% DV | 1650 mghigher72% DV |
| Carbohydrates | 30 g11% DV | 32 ghigher12% DV |
| Fiber | 1 g4% DV | 2 ghigher7% DV |
| Sugars | 8 g | 8 g |
| Protein | 35 g | 35 g |
| Protein per 100 calories | 5.8 g | 5.7 g |
| Share of a 2,000-calorie day | 30% | 31% |
“Higher” marks the larger number only; it is not a judgement. % DV is the FDA Daily Value for a 2,000-calorie diet, shown for nutrients that have one.
Allergens in Sonic's guide
Sonic's allergen guide does not list Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) as a single item (it lists parts only, or the item is not in it), so we cannot compare allergens here. Check the allergen menu.
This lists what Sonic marks as contained. Cross-contact can happen in the kitchen, so use the allergen menu if you avoid an allergen.
Original SONIC Smasher (Double) vs All-American SONIC Smasher (Double): Questions
Answers use only the numbers in Sonic's guides.
Which has more calories, Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double)?
All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) has more calories: 610 against 600 for Original SONIC Smasher (Double). Figures are from Sonic's nutrition guides.
Which has more protein, Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double)?
Original SONIC Smasher (Double) and All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) have the same protein (35 g g).
Which has more sodium, Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double)?
All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) has more sodium: 1650 mg against 1530 mg for Original SONIC Smasher (Double).
Which has more sugar, Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double)?
Original SONIC Smasher (Double) and All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) have the same sugar (8 g g).
Do Original SONIC Smasher (Double) and All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) contain the same allergens?
Sonic's allergen guide does not list Original SONIC Smasher (Double) or All-American SONIC Smasher (Double) as a single item (it lists parts only, or the item is not in it), so we cannot compare allergens here. Check the allergen menu.
More Sonic Comparisons
Each page puts two items side by side with the numbers from Sonic's guides.
- Tots (Medium) vs Groovy Fries (Medium)
- Cheese Tots (Medium) vs Cheese Groovy Fries (Medium)
- Mozzarella Sticks (Medium) vs Onion Rings (Medium)
- Corn Dog vs Chili Cheese Coney
- Corn Dog vs All-American Hot Dog
- Chili Cheese Coney vs Footlong Quarter Pound Coney
- SONIC Cheeseburger with Ketchup & Mayo vs SuperSONIC Double Cheeseburger with Ketchup & Mayo
- Jr. Double Cheeseburger vs Original SONIC Smasher (Double)
- Smoked Gouda and Bacon SONIC Smasher vs Original SONIC Smasher (Double)
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich vs SONIC Cheeseburger with Ketchup & Mayo
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich vs Crispy Chicken Sandwich
- Premium Chicken Bites (Medium) vs Chicken Tenders (5 Pc)
- Breakfast Burrito Bacon vs Breakfast Burrito Sausage
- Cherry Limeade (Medium) vs Ocean Water (Medium)
- Cherry Limeade (Medium) vs Cherry Limeade (Large)
- Cherry Limeade (Medium) vs Diet Cherry Limeade (Medium)
- Ocean Water (Medium) vs Twisted Flamingo (Medium)
- Coca-Cola (Medium) vs Coca-Cola Zero Sugar (Medium)
- Cherry Cream Slush (Medium) vs Strawberry Cream Slush (Medium)
- Chocolate Shake (Medium) vs Strawberry Shake (Medium)
- OREO Chocolate Shake (Medium) vs OREO Cheesecake Shake (Medium)
- Chocolate Shake (Medium) vs SONIC Blast with OREO Cookie Pieces (Medium)
- Hot Fudge Sundae vs Vanilla Soft Serve Cup
- Santa Slush Float (Medium) vs Barq’s Root Beer Float
Where the Numbers Come From
We are an independent guide, not Sonic or Inspire Brands.
Sources
- Sonic's Fall 2026 nutrition guide: every value for regular menu items.
- Sonic's Fall 2026 allergen guide: the allergens marked for each item.
- Sonic's November 2026 brochure: limited-time items, flagged on the page.
What it does not do
- It adds, multiplies and compares Sonic's numbers. It does not estimate anything.
- It leaves out items that are not in the Fall 2026 guide, and drink add-ins and burger add-ons.
- It does not compare prices, because Sonic publishes none.
- It does not call any item healthier. “Higher” only marks the larger number.
Sonic publishes no menu prices. Prices on Sonic Menu are not Sonic's: where we could, we show a typical pickup price measured by Drive Thru Index across a sample of Sonic restaurant pages (checked November 6, 2026); for a few items we could not measure, a rough estimate of our own. They are not live prices from any single restaurant. Exact menu prices, combo meal promotions, and product availability vary by independent franchise location, drive-in stall vs. drive-thru, and delivery service app markups (DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub).